Catholic priest ordered to remove ‘Jesus had two dads’ sign

Illustrated rainbow pride flag on a pink background.

A Catholic church in New York has been forced to remove a sign that reads ā€˜Jesus had two dads and he turned out fineā€™.

Rev. Roy Herberger, of St Columbia-Brigid Roman Catholic Church in Buffalo, New York, put up the comical message last week.

The priest says the message wasnā€™t actually intended to support LGBT rights, and was meant to be an encouraging children who have heterosexual step-parents.

However, he was besieged with complaints from parishioners and other hardcore Catholics who interpreted it as an endorsement of same-sex parenting, which Church doctrine condemns.

His boss was among those who werenā€™t amused by the message ā€“ ordering the sign to be removed.

Bishop Richard J Malone of the Catholic Diocese of Buffalo said in a statement: ā€œAs soon as I learned of this sign, I took immediate action to have it removed.

ā€œThe pastor told me that the ā€˜2 Dadsā€™ were meant to refer to a child who has both a father and stepfather.

ā€œThere are several children in his parish who have both a father and stepfather.

ā€œHowever, given the potential for the meaning of this message to be misunderstood and even perceived in a heretical way, it was immediately removed.ā€

Herberger, who says he got the sign idea after looking on the internet, insisted to Yahoo: ā€œI only had one purposeā€¦ After 48 years in the church, I see so many kids with stepparents, or even in single-family homes or being raised by grandparents, who feel that theyā€™re not as good as other kids who have a nuclear mother-and-father family.
Catholic priest ordered to remove ‘Jesus had two dads’ sign
ā€œIā€™ve seen what that does sometimes when theyā€™re comparing themselves to that nuclear family, and I wanted to say, ā€˜Hang in there. Youā€™re good. Things will work out for youā€™.

ā€œI wanted to provide support and understanding for kids in that situation.ā€

John Vennari, a writer with Catholic Family News ā€“ listed as an extremist Radical Traditional Catholic group by the Southern Poverty Law Center ā€“ had ranted about the sign.

The anti-LGBT writer had complained: ā€œThis pro-homosexual sign effectively mocks the Blessed Trinity, mocks the Hypostatic Union, mocks the Holy Family of Jesus, Mary and Joseph ā€“ some of the most sacred components of our Catholic Faith.ā€