Annie Proulx says Brokeback Mountain’s characters ‘were not gay’ until halfway through the story
Annie Proulx at the 68th National Book Awards (Getty Images)
Annie Proulx has revealed she only decided the central men in Brokeback Mountain were gay partway through writing the story, after a chance encounter with a restaurant owner who complained about serving “two gay men”.
Speaking on NPR’s Weekend Edition Saturday, the 91-year-old author told host Scott Simon: “They were not gay until a certain point in the story.”
Proulx said the turning point came when she stopped for lunch at “a strange little restaurant on a back road”, where the proprietress was “in a roaring, stamping temper”. The woman, Proulx recalled, ranted about two guests from the night before who were “obviously two gay men”, adding that she “didn’t like it, and served them rather badly and asked them to leave”.
Proulx said she had not witnessed the incident herself, but hearing the account changed her own work. “And at that point, I was about half done with my story of these two sheep herders. And I made them gay after that story,” she said.
In the NPR interview, she revealed the last line she added to “Brokeback Mountain”: “There was some open space between what he knew and what he tried to believe, but nothing could be done about it. And if you can’t fix it, you’ve got to stand it.”
How did the restaurant encounter change the story?

Proulx also pushed back on the shorthand that has followed Brokeback Mountain for decades. “But the story itself is really not about two cowboys,” she said. “It’s about two guys who could not find any work in Wyoming except herding sheep, which is very much a unwanted job.”
When Simon suggested that meant it was “a sheep-herding story, not a love story”, Proulx replied: “Yeah. It turned into a love story late in the game.”
The comments were made as Proulx promotes her new collection Annie Proulx Stories, which spans five decades and includes “Brokeback Mountain”.
Why Brokeback Mountain remains a queer touchstone
First published in 1997, “Brokeback Mountain” follows a decades-long, secret relationship between Ennis Del Mar and Jack Twist. It was later adapted into Ang Lee’s 2005 film starring Heath Ledger and Jake Gyllenhaal.
In 2020, Proulx said she wished she’d never written the story because “so many people miss the point of it”.